Someone should stick a spoiler warning on this thread
Originally posted by LeHah
Episode 1 invalidated the entire "Jedi Academy" idea from it's inception. Yoda says that Qui-Gon can only have a single Padawan in his charge, which is not the case when Luke finds people like Kyp and company in Anderson's novel, Jedi Search. Then there's "Midichlorians" which undoes Anderson's dumb "Force Testing" machine that has Luke flying across rooms when he probes his sister's mind in the aforementioned book.
Far be it from me to defend Anderson, I suggest that these can be 'explained away' in a similar way to 'inconsistencies' in the WCU. Remember that information about the Jedi would have been purged just as much as the Jedi themselves, so it's not too hard to imagine that Luke would not know about only having one Padawan at a time. Not to mention that since he's the only Jedi left at that time, so to train one Jedi at a time would be impractical.
About the Force testing machine and mind prodding, I didn't like those ideas, so they can be tossed out.
But could using midichlorians just be the primary method of finding potential Jedi?
Originally posted by LeHah
Episode 2 was pretty lame IMHO. Though it's better than Episode 1, it lacks the basic fluidity that the story needed. Things just seemed to happen "Look! An assassin! Get him! Wait! She's Dead! It was another assassin! Chase him! Go that way! I'll seduce Portman!". It just jumped around and a lot of things went unexplained (Ex: why do Geonosians dislike Jedi and Seantors enough to put them in an ARENA?!) and motives seemed muddled.
I
loved Episode II, now that I've finally seen it. But I agree, there was so much going on, it's hard to discern the motives of the multitudes of factions.
Originally posted by junior
Episode II also messes with the Thrawn books, if only because AotC pretty much rewrites everything we 'knew' about the clones prior to this. Of course, Zahn had only used the popular theory about the Clone Wars. Not much that he could have done about that. And some elements of it could still prove to be correct.
Yeah, that confused me, I thought the clones were supposed to be the bad guys. But I don't understand who the clones are being sent to fight at the end. The Empire has pretty much been formed in all but name now, with Palpatine gaining "special powers", but is it possible that the clones turn on their 'masters'?
Originally posted by LeHah
Another big thing lost is the sense of "realism" in the prequels. Anyone else notice all the ships are sparkling new and shiny?
Uh, they didn't look
that shiny to me. And as you said, these are still pre-Empire days.
Originally posted by junior
The explanation is that, whether he knows it or not, Han is Force Sensitive, and 'unconsciously channels the Force' when he uses Luke's lightsaber. No, I didn't say it made a whole lot of sense. Nor do I agree with it at all.
I never heard of this idea of lightsabres chanelling the Force, myself, I only thought the Force was used in the constructing the lightsabre, aligning the crystals used to focus the beam. After that, it's a purely mechanical device.
Originally posted by junior
There's nothing to indicate that the cloners are being completely honest in their dealings with the Republic.
That's what I was thinking.
Originally posted by junior
And the gleaming silver on the Naboo liners doesn't help much, either.
I thought the silver was right, given that Amidala is supposed to be the distinguished representative of Naboo.
Originally posted by junior
But the exteriors of the war machines for the Grand Army of the Republic were perfect, I thought. The walkers that we saw in the movie looked very much like something that might evolve into the fearsome AT-AT, and the wedge-shaped starships looked an awful lot like one might imagine an early Star Destroyer to be.
Definitely, this is clearly the impression they were supposed to give.
Originally posted by Frosty
Pretty much all the glitter came from Naboo. One could assume that it's just an affectation of their culture.
Yes.
Originally posted by Col.Dom
WHERE WAS THE MANDALORIAN ARMY!?
I heard about this on the net several years back. I always thought it was a fake story.
Originally posted by Ender
[Palpatine is] already chancellor...
He's already Emperor in all but name with his "special powers".
Originally posted by Filler
The clones' armour looked a lot like Jango's/Boba's armour.
Stormtroopers, rather.
Originally posted by LeHah
Lucas said to forget everything you knew about Fett...
Where? When?