What do U think about this thought?

Tommieboy

Spaceman
Hello,

wouldn't it be great, if Origin would produce
remakes of Wing Commander 1&2?

Just like it was tried a few years ago on the 3DO and PowerMac
system wih SUPER-Wing Commander?

Wouldn't it be great?

Of course not to re-design the Ships, but to enhance the
Movie-sequences, Music and the other Stuff?

Would You then buy these Games?:D
 
Super Wing Commander is nearly ten years old. This question has come up about three hundred times, and I think the general consensus has been that it'd be much better if Origin or whomever focused their resources on a new game..
 
Well Sorry, I haven't seen a thread regarding this matter
anywhere!

These Games mustn't be developed by the important Members of Origin themselves!

Maybe they can be made by another department?

But if no ones interested in this discussion anymore, then plse ignore it!!!
 
There's a few reasons why a simple remake isn't likely, though:

* You're talking about developing a game based on twelve year old unfamiliar code (the people who developed the original WC games are all gone) which in all likelyhood doesn't exist anymore.

* It didn't sell the last time they tried it. People didn't buy Kilrathi Saga... and Origin dropped any plans to 'upgrade' more old games (hence the promised Ultima Collection became shovelware). When there's no money in it, there's no interest.
 
Originally posted by Bandit LOAF
There's a few reasons why a simple remake isn't likely, though:

* You're talking about developing a game based on twelve year old unfamiliar code (the people who developed the original WC games are all gone) which in all likelyhood doesn't exist anymore.

* It didn't sell the last time they tried it. People didn't buy Kilrathi Saga... and Origin dropped any plans to 'upgrade' more old games (hence the promised Ultima Collection became shovelware). When there's no money in it, there's no interest.

I have a few prob's w/ what you just said:

1) A remake wouldn't be based on "unfamiliar code"; the code could (and by definition pretty much *would*) be all-new. Rather, it's the spirit, storyline, events, etc. of the old game that would be be retained from the "old" game. That makes it hella less hard to do than what yer proposing (--if I understood U correctly)

2) Sure, KS didn't sell too well the first time around. However, w/ the prices it's fetching on e-bay/etc. these days, is there any doubt that there would be a healthy amount of interest/$$$/profit in it for Origin/EA if they were to re-issue WC: KS?...

After all, there's a loyal core of WC nuts like us already out there, and they already have the game "in the can"; they wouldn't have to re-write nothing. All they'd hafta do is just dust off the old masters and press a limited-run # of copies for sale.

Whatever money they'd wanna sink into advertising for it would be proportional to the size of the run they're planning. Then they could close up shop on it for anopther 5 years, and bring out another limited-run, etc.--rather like Disney does with their old "classics on VHS" (Fantasia, etc.... and don't even get me started on Disney...grrr...)
 
1) A remake wouldn't be based on "unfamiliar code"; the code could (and by definition pretty much *would*) be all-new. Rather, it's the spirit, storyline, events, etc. of the old game that would be be retained from the "old" game. That makes it hella less hard to do than what yer proposing (--if I understood U correctly)

Alternatively, making an entirely *new* game is at the very least multi-million dollar prospect in this day and age...

(Still, the original request was for a game that was 'Just like it was tried a few years ago on the 3DO and PowerMac system wih SUPER-Wing Commander?' -- which was just a redress of WC1... same code, different graphics.)

2) Sure, KS didn't sell too well the first time around. However, w/ the prices it's fetching on e-bay/etc. these days, is there any doubt that there would be a healthy amount of interest/$$$/profit in it for Origin/EA if they were to re-issue WC: KS?...

The ten people who constantly fight over Kilrathi Saga on eBay do not a market base make. It's just a case of two people wanting one item and the price going up because of this... there's not a huge, profit-making demand for Kilrathi Saga.

After all, there's a loyal core of WC nuts like us already out there, and they already have the game "in the can"; they wouldn't have to re-write nothing. All they'd hafta do is just dust off the old masters and press a limited-run # of copies for sale.

... which they tried about a year after Kilrathi Saga came out. And it flopped again. The internet is not a good indication of anything.
 
::watches the internet stupidity meter dip into the red when Preacher makes yet another silly comment::
 
Originally posted by Mav23
technically... wouldn't a stupidity meter *climb* when a silly comment was made? :p

Apparently, this one measures stupidity by checking the relative IQ levels in a room and then shows it dropping with each stupid question made.
 
Originally posted by Mav23
technically... wouldn't a stupidity meter *climb* when a silly comment was made? :p

...And so, Lehah contributes to his very creation...:D
 
Originally posted by Haesslich
Apparently, this one measures stupidity by checking the relative IQ levels in a room and then shows it dropping with each stupid question made.

Wow, you seem to know quite a lot about the workings of a stupidity meter, this frightens Mav ;)
 
Originally posted by Preacher


After all, there's a loyal core of WC nuts like us already out there, and they already have the game

I dont want to look bad or something but I believe that there are not so many "wingnuts" and loyal WcFans anymore.Even in here I think that the half of the people here dont really care about the fate of the Wc series...Many of them have Wc products Pirate etc

In a lot of threads I saw "Its a real opurtunity to buy The WCM DVD cause its cheap now" or something like that.I didnt like WCM a lot but I took the DVD when it came out without questioning myself.CAUSE IM A FAN.As I said before ,even if Origin make a new WC product a few of us is going to support WC buying it
 
Back
Top