In my mind, there are several reasons we do not allow piracy here.
- No matter whether or not you have convinced yourself that it is moral, it is still illegal. This site and the community as a whole have always enjoyed a good working relationship with Wing Commander's copyright holders. I, personally, have no desire to see this damaged on account of someone not wanting to shell out five bucks for something.
- These games are still making money for their copywrite holders. Would Destination have been as interested in licensing a port of Wing Commander Prophecy if the original game were readily available on the internet? I'm sure you can download Wing Commander games somewhere -- but the minute the center of the online community starts condoning this, there is a significant decline in value.
- No matter what you have convinced yourself, piracy is simply selfishness. It is in no way a 'demonstration' to the world that there is interest in the franchise. It is entirely the desire to get something for nothing. I do not necessarily have anything against this concept -- but it is completely counter to how a community operates.
- The issue of respect, both self and community-wide. We love Wing Commander... aren't we willing to spend a few bucks to show that? Certainly, Electronic Arts isn't going to get any of the five dollars I might spend to buy a copy of Wing 2... but I'll feel better about myself, I'll have more respect for the product and having actually spent something on the game will help build a better, less selfish community.