Eh, it's actually not all that bad
Heya, fellas.
I picked up Fable the day it came out. Truthfully, I wasn't all that impressed at first. Though the graphics were pretty cool (is it just my imagination, or does the whole world operate around a day to night to day cycle, so you can actually see the sun rise, or watch lights turn on in towns at night?), the game started out pretty slow...starting with a segment at the beginning where you need to do good or evil acts to save up enough money to buy your sister a present for her birthday, then after a massacre in the town, you join this Guild of Heroes where you start training with swordplay, archery, and magic for awhile (they obviously did this as a bit of a tutorial to get you used to some of the basic controls of the game)...
But...ASSUMING you can live through all of that (it was a struggle for me!), the game definitely does pick up after it, I thought. The quests you do can be pretty thrilling, and seem to be getting better the further you go. There is quite a bit of content in the game. After you kill this giant bee harrassing a picnic on your first quest, you can parade around with its head and show it to as many people as you can find in a given time limit in order to gain fame.
I've come to love the music in the game...I'm weird like that - being a bit musically inclined, I listen for catchy tunes even in video games...the graphics are pretty nice like I say (the lighting is actually pretty amazing...depending on the time of day, some people almost seem to glow in the sunlight which creates a cool luminescent effect), some of the battles can be fairly thrilling from an action standpoint (it's not just click a guy to attack, you have to somewhat aim your attacks, time your special moves, block, switch between magic, melee, and your bow)...and the fact that you communicate through an ever-increasing number of gestures is kind of a neat idea.
I think the only problem that Fable has was that the company that was developing it promised more than they could deliver, so it could never live up to all the hype. Originally, I think they had their hopes high - promising things like leaving footprints on the ground, having more depth to the NPCs that aren't involved in the major plot, having multiplayer (which would have been AWESOME), etc. And in the end, they couldn't do it all...or rather, maybe they could have, but not before the second generation XBox would come out and people wouldn't care about Fable anymore.
As for the game itself, though...I'm pretty thrilled with it, I have to say. Once you get into it, I think it's kind of hard to put down. Unlike you, Shipgate, I'm more a swordsman myself. And they did a pretty fantastic job with the character development as well. Whereas Shipgate's character's hair is turning gray because he's using magic, my character's face looks a little beat up with a few scars and slashes from his close encounters in melee combat.
I'd recommend getting the game if you like RPGs and a game that's pretty rich in content. I think the largest game names I've heard up until now in the RPG industry (not counting all those annoying MMORPGs that are about) are "Neverwinter Nights" and "Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic," both put out by Bioware. While I did like both, I was just never a huge SW:KOTOR fan - always found that I could put that down whenever I wanted and didn't really care even IF Bastila was egging me on! - so I would have to say that (again - this is just in my own opinion) Fable is better than SW:KOTOR. I wouldn't go so far as to place it in higher regard than Neverwinter Nights, though...I would think NWN could pretty much accomplish all the same stuff with slightly less impressive graphics. The fact that you can make your own adventures in NWN, though, would have to make it infinitely better than any pre-designed RPG.
But if you're an RPG fan, like I say, Fable is at least worth a rent to look into. It might not be all they originally promised...but I think it's pretty decent and entertaining for what it is.
The only reason I myself haven't played it lately is because I'm not that huge an RPG fan...and with Burnout 3 out now as well as Star Wars: Battlefront, ehhh....there's only so many hours in the day, ya know?

(Oh, and not to deviate from the topic at hand, but just a little plug here - if you haven't already, DEFINITELY look into these 2 titles if you're an XBox owner!)
Anyway, that's just my 2 cents...
- FireFalcon ~};^