your spur of the moment 27th century simile is a tinderbox? *Really*?)
Granted, you'd expect a whole new set of similes to have evolved by the 27th century... but then we'd probably end up seeing some idiotic new swearwords of the "frak" variety. Next thing you know, Cobra would probably have used WC-frak twice in every sentence, to show how dark and edgy she is - because that's ever-so-cool.
I remember thinking that all the cursing in Wing Commander II was *so* risqué at the time. Little did I know...
(Was Stingray "she went up like a tinderbox!" when he destroyed a capital ship? That one always got me -- your spur of the moment 27th century simile is a tinderbox? *Really*?)
If we're including the novels, I've always been fond of: Bugs Bunny screws his mother.
I can't even put my finger on it -- but something inside my brain groans whenever I hear it mentioned.
Easy....
"Die by the very weapons you adore!"
Well, it is something that depends on implementation. I have to admit, I have always thought the fake swearwords in Firefly were really well done - for the simple reason that they were used exactly the same way real swearwords would and could have been used. Saying "Gorram" instead of "God damn" is purely a flavour choice - they could have used "God damn", and it wouldn't have affected the show, because it's still a fairly mild swearword, and because it's used so rarely. The first time I watched Firefly, I thought they just spoke "God damn" with a weird accent - it took me a few episodes to catch the notion that it was a made-up word.I'll agree with you there, I can't stand that stuff. Although, we did have some Kilrathi swearing...
(And as personally annoying as the proliferation of Battlestar Galactica and Firefly pretend-swearing is today, I do remember a brief infatuation with Larry Niven's equivalent as a teenager. I guess it's something you grow out of, which--as stupid as it seems--is something to keep in mind when writing for an audience.)
Well, it is something that depends on implementation. I have to admit, I have always thought the fake swearwords in Firefly were really well done - for the simple reason that they were used exactly the same way real swearwords would and could have been used. Saying "Gorram" instead of "God damn" is purely a flavour choice - they could have used "God damn", and it wouldn't have affected the show, because it's still a fairly mild swearword, and because it's used so rarely. The first time I watched Firefly, I thought they just spoke "God damn" with a weird accent - it took me a few episodes to catch the notion that it was a made-up word.
On the other hand, the swearing in Battlestar Galactica (and, earlier, in Farscape) was terrible. It probably started off the same way as in Firefly, as a flavour choice - but it ended up childishly overused as a cheap way of making the show vulgar without having to deal with TV rules governing the use of swearwords. Look at us, we can say "fuck" fifty times in one show and nobody can complain because it's not really "fuck"! It's just plain childish - nobody in their right minds would use "fuck" multiple times because it loses impact and ends up sounding awful, so whatever made them think that it was all right to do it with "frak"?
(of course, there's also the reception by the fans, which is another matter, and the great equaliser between Firefly and BSG. Seeing "Gorram" all over the internet is no less irritating than "frak")
Well, quite likely - but the thing is, fiction is not reality, nor is it ever meant to be. That's one mistake very frequently made by beginner and/or incompetent writers (I should know, I committed similar things a few times in Standoff ) - you assume that if someone would say something in reality, then that's how it should be in fiction, too. But it just doesn't work that way. The greatest works of fiction are those that completely flaunt reality. No living person could ever keep up with Shakespeare's characters - what kind of an idiot would end his life saying "Oh, I am slain!", and who'd ever have the presence of mind to always have a witty speech ready for the right occasion? In other words - yes, a real person in a BSG situation would probably break down and use "fuck" as noun, adjective and verb in every sentence... but that's just not good writing.As for the level of swearing, if I were in some (well most tbh)of the situations they find themselves in in BSG, I'd be swearing to an Olympic level .