I liked the Claw, myself. Call me old fashion, but I like everything from WC1, which is why I liked Prophecy so much.
It had the same feeling to it. Even the bar\barracks from the claw had the same layout as the Bar\Ready room of the Midway.
The Hornet and the Pirahna
The Scimitar and the Shrike
The Vampire and the Rapier
What a great couple of games those were.
Anyhow, I like the Claw best, then the Midway, then the Victory. The Victory didn't really have that much, but because we got to see most of the ship, and it was so interactive, it rocked.