WC vs. History: Tools of the Trade (June 6, 2011)

Bandit LOAF

Long Live the Confederation!
midwayheader.png

In today's Battle of Midway commemorative update we're going to look at four aircraft and one ship that served during the battle--and the Wing Commander equivalents named in their honor!

At the close of the Terran-Kilrathi war the F2M Vindicator was one of the most popular Home Defense planes. A "jack of all trades but master of none", the Vindicator was an ideal choice for units on distant frontier worlds who might be called upon to fly many mission types with a single ship. Vindicator units went on to serve aboard the makeshift carriers that formed the backbone of the Outerworlds Fleet.

The Vought SB2U Vindicator was a mid-1930s American naval dive bomber design. It served on four American carriers during the interwar and early war years. It also served with the US Marine Corps, the French Navy, and the Royal Navy. By the outbreak of World War II, they were obsolete but were still in service in some roles until 1943. During the Battle of Midway, a group of Vindicators, part of Marine squadron VMSB-241, led by Major Benjamin W. Norris attacked the battleship Haruna at 0820 am. They bracketed the ship with five or six near misses but they caused no damage. Marine pilots who had gone on to fly the Douglas SBD Dauntless called the SB2U's with disdain “vibrators” or “wind indicators.”




The TB-80A Devastator was the Terran Confederation's premiere torpedo bomber at the outset of the Nephilim invasion. Devastators were larger bombers designed to fly off of fleet carriers like the Vesuvius and Midway classes. Dotted with defensive turrets, Devastators also mounted a central plasma cannon that would shake up established fighter strike doctrine. Devastators played a major role in the destruction of the Nephilim wormhole gate at Kilrah.

The Douglass TBD Devastator torpedo bomber entered service in 1937. It was obsolete by 1941. Affectionately called the “torpecker” it lacked speed and maneuverability needed to fight amongst carrier fighters in 1942. This plane is best remembered during the Battle of Midway for the attacks of VT-8, -6, and -3. The 15 planes of VT-8 launched from the USS Hornet were annihilated during their attack run save for one more, Ensign George Gay. VT-6 and VT-3 also suffered under the guns of Japanese Zeroes during the battle.




The Union of Border World's TBP Avenger is an unlikely torpedo plane. Used as S&R craft during the Terran-Kilrathi War, these 'flying bricks' would prove to be an unusually effective striking platform during the 2673 secession crisis. Even Colonel Seether flew an Avenger at one point--destroying the Orlando Depot as part of the plot to convince Colonel Blair to support Tolwyn's move towards war.

The Grumman TBF Avenger was a modern torpedo bomber that entered service in 1942 and first saw action in the Battle of Midway in June 1942. It was a vast improvement over the TBD. It had greater range, speed, payload, and armor than the TBD. It carried its ordinance internally which improved airflow around the aircraft for improved performance. During the Battle of Midway, six planes of Torpedo 8 based on the island used TBF Avengers to attack the Japanese carriers without success. Only one of the six aircraft survived the attack. The Avenger went on to participate in every subsequent Pacific carrier operation. TBFs sank a great number of ships and most famously put a large number of torpedoes into each of the Yamato class battleships, Yamato and Musashi.




When the Terran Confederation first went to war, the Wildcat was the Navy's front line space interceptor. The Wildcat was able, if aging. A c50 million, thirty year old design whose upgrade program died in the senate, Wildcats none-the-less served admirably in the war's first battles. The Wildcat mounted two lasers and two mass drivers and carried seven missiles (six guided, one dumb fire). Ensign Geoffrey Tolwyn, never trained on the fighter, flew a pair of missions in them during the catastrophic McAuliffe Ambush.

The Grumman F4F Wildcat fighter entered service in 1940. It served throughout the Pacific War. During the early part of the war it was the only effective carrier fighter available to American forces. With the introduction of the Thach Weave in the spring of 1942, the Wildcat became a difficult opponent for the Japanese Zero. However, it was still outclassed by a Zero piloted by a superior pilot. Throughout the Pacific War the Wildcat earned a 6:9 kill-to-loss ratio, which pales in comparison to its successor, the F6F Hellcat which finished the war with a 19:1 ratio and over 300 aces.




When we set out to write this update we planned to look at the Order of Battle at Midway and write about all the ships in Wing Commander's coninuity that shared their names. What we discovered is that that only one warship at the Battle of Midway has its name used in Wing Commander--and, a bigger surprise, it was a Japanese carrier. Her Wing Commander ancestor is the TCS Soryu, mentioned in passing in Action Stations:
"The carriers we do have, other than Concordia, were launched before I was even born. They're antiques, held together with spit and duct tape. Even though Soryu is listed as being on-line, the truth is she's nothing more than a floating stockpile for spare parts, which get stripped out to keep the other five like her going. The fleet spends nearly sixty percent of its time docked right upstairs to save on engine time," and as he spoke he pointed up to where the fleet was now docked at Alexandria.
The Japanese carrier Soryu (Japanese for Blue Dragon) was commissioned in 1937. Soryu would become one of the core members of Kido Butai, or the First Air Fleet. Kido Butai was the first carrier centric striking force in the world. Soryu would participate in many prewar exercises and the early war engagements until it met destiny off Midway in June 1942. Soryu took part in the strike on Pearl Harbor with her planes attacking Battleship Row. One of her B5N “Kate” torpedo bombers put the torpedo into the Arizona that eventually sank the battleship. On the way back from the Pearl Harbor Raid, Soryu and sister ship Hiryu were detached to support the Japanese invasion of Wake Island. In February 1942, she along with the rest of Kido Butai launched an air raid against Darwin, Australia. She also fought in the Battle of the Java Sea. At the beginning of April 1942, Soryu took part in an operation into the Indian Ocean. The Japanese raided the British on the island of Ceylon. They took part in the sinking the cruisers Cornwall and Dorsetshire and the carrier Hermes and her escorting destroyer Vampire. She also chased after the USS Hornet and Enterprise following the Doolittle Raid to no success. It was on June 4, 1942 that the Soryu met her end. During the 1020-1025 dive bomber attack, the Soryu took three 1,000 pound bombs. These started uncontrollable fires in the hangar decks full of fuel and partially armed strike planes with ordnance stacked around the hangar because of Admiral Nagumo's rearming orders and counter-orders. She sank at 1913 pm taking 711 of 1,103 crew to a deep grave off Midway.




Tomorrow: Midway's legacy in both the 20th and 27th Centuries.

Very special thanks to this update (and series)'s history author, Dundradal.

--
Original update published on June 6, 2011
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I actually used the WC Vindicator quite a bit in WC4. I liked the tachyon/laser setup and packing a torpedo, even though it lacked in most other areas.

I just never liked the look of the Avenger. It did have nice guns, but just the idea of being in a ship that ugly bothered me :p
 
For everyone wondering (... all none of you...) the designations for the Border World fighters are non canon (GASP). They're from a series of articles we wrote for EA that were SUPPOSED to be published at their XBLA/Arena site... but they lost interest before any of that happened. Boo.

The Avenger is a tough ship to figure out. Like the Longbow, it's hard to connect its appearance on Wing Commander Academy with the ship we see in Wing Commander IV.
 
Another fun historical note: There's actually two designations for the Avenger. The TBF Avenger was manufactured by Grumman. All the Avengers at Midway and in the early war were TBF avengers. Late in the war, because Grumman didn't have the production capacity to support both Avenger and F6F Hellcat orders, Avenger production was taken over by General Motors. The GM-built avengers were designated "TBM Avengers".

One of the most famous WW2 Avenger pilots was named George H. W. Bush. He was shot down over the island of Chichi Jima late in the war, and was the only survivor from his plane. Of the dozen or so pilots shot down over ChiChi Jima in that time period, he was the only one that escaped capture by the Japanese, and hence the only one that escaped being murdered (and in most cases, cannibalized) by the Japanese garrison on the island. (This information is related in the nonfiction work Flyboys...good read if anyone is interested).
 
What we discovered is that that only one warship at the Battle of Midway has its name used in Wing Commander

What about the Yorktown? Isn't there a Yorktown in Wing Commander? The Victory is a Yorktown-class carrier, isn't she? (Or is she a Ranger-class? I'm still confused about that...) If she was Yorktown-class, that at least implies that there was a TCS Yorktown at some point, right?
 
Yeah, the Yorktown class was named specifically after the Yorktown at Midway... (currently in part).

Wait, Loaf you named it? The Star Soldier Commentary gave me the impression that the people who wrote Star Soldier came up with the name on their own. Maybe I just misread that.
 
Yeah, the Yorktown class was named specifically after the Yorktown at Midway... (currently in part).

I'm pretty sure it was named for the Battle of Yorktown.


Yes, lots of details I left out (TBF vs TBM)...some of these updates have been the longest in CIC history. (I think the Torpedo 8 was...it was something like 4 pages in Word). So I tried to keep these ones shorter and comparable to the amount of info LOAF could do on the WC side.
 
Actually this is the text I was referring to before.

"Yorktown" - WC3 light carrier. Okay, this was probably the most discussed ship name in Star*Soldier (which is something, since I had a transport named after Kelly Clarkson... whoops). Here's the deal: compared to all this trivia, the one 'empty' WC3 ship name which has most frustrated fans over the years has been this one. Sure, it's annoying not knowing the escorts... but not knowing what the ship you're on? Madness, cats and dogs living together, Russians and Americans on the same space station. This will give you an idea of how long I've been around: when Wing Commander III came out, we called it Victory-class because of a reference to 'Victory class transports' in Fleet Action. The assumption being - for whatever reason - that the Victory must be a converted transport. Years later we adopted 'Ranger-class' after a reference in Action Stations. I was all set to go with that here... but then I checked it. The novel doesn't mention a Ranger light carrier, it mentions a Ranger carrier. The intention of the passage was different than I had thought - the ship was supposed to be old, not small. So I named it after the aircraft carrier that came one after the original USS Ranger, the USS Yorktown.
 
Heh. So "Ranger class" was scrapped and replaced with "Yorktown Class" because Action Stations implies that the Ranger class was old but not small...and the Victory was supposed to be old AND small? So Yorktown was chosen instead because, historically, the Yorktown came right after Ranger.

The irony, of course, is that the real U.S.S. Ranger WAS essentially a light carrier, and was very small. In fact, it proved too small to be useful, and one reason why Yorktown was designed and why it became the main class of pre-war U.S. carriers was because Ranger wasn't big enough.

So the Victory's class gets named after the Yorktown, not the Ranger, because the assumption from Action Stations was that Ranger was too big, but in real life Ranger was the small carrier and Yorktown was the big one. :-)
 
So the Victory's class gets named after the Yorktown, not the Ranger, because the assumption from Action Stations was that Ranger was too big, but in real life Ranger was the small carrier and Yorktown was the big one. :-)

Action Stations is the mother of all paradoxes.
 
Back
Top