I liked the pilot of space above and beyond, the show got weirder as it went on.
You have to have good character interation, this is very important among the lead characters. Blair and maniac from WC3, and WC4 were great they did a good job, I wanted more from WCP. I don't remember the interaction between Space Above and Beyond, besides a badass pilot who couldn't fly anymore, and they guy with the big ears and the girl who were badass pilots. Luke and Han were another great example (something that the new SW movies haven't done is the interaction between characters, gotta love Harrison for Han).
Lack of good interaction is one of the reasons some of the ST series have strugged, they never captured the original trio (Kirk, Spock, and McCoy).
And you can't forget about the original Starbuck, he was one of the best things about Battlestar Galactica.