WC Academy issue and WC2

Dran

Nothing is written here
Recently viewed an episode of WCA. In which there were stealth fighters. The issue I have with this is Tolyn says he was wrong. These stealth fighters were also the reason for the Tiger Claw's destruction in which our hero Cris Blair is demoted to captin, and again Tolyn reams him out. Can anybody explain this to me?
 
The stealth fighters in WCA were invisible to radar and other non-visible-band sensor technology, but were visible to the human (and presumably Kilrathi) eye. The stealth fighters in WC2 and later were invisible to the eye as well as to machines. The in-universe explaination behind this is that it is extremely hard to make your ship transparent to visible light without blocking outside light from reaching the pilot (i.e. the pilot would have to fly blind because he can't see out through the cloak). Remember how the Skipper missile had to decloak in order to see its target?
 
It might also be possible that Tolwyn actually believed Blair with the stealth fighters (or at least didn't rule out the possibility completely), but needed a culprint and he was ideal for that spot?
 
It's possible, but I always thought it was more likely that Tolwyn didn't believe Blair precisely because of the previous stealth fighter encounter. I mean, logically, Blair is the only one who could be expected to make up a lie about Kilrathi stealth fighters - nobody else would, because it didn't occur to anybody else that such a thing could exist. And it would seem rather odd to Tolwyn that these Kilrathi stealth fighters would conveniently pop up right when Blair needed to justify an enormous failure... besides, what's the likelihood of one pilot running into stealth fighters twice in the space of about two years, when nobody else ever saw them?
 
ok well I'll except that for now.

You probably mean 'accept'. "Except" means to exclude.

The photon cloak has been accepted science since the mid-2640s. However, until the Empire of Kilrah premiered the Strakha in 2656 the technology was considered a tactical dead end (and that's looking at this with the eyes of history -- in reality, this was not realized by the Confederation until 2667).

There are two reasons for this. As already stated, the theory behind the photon cloak required it to be 'double blind' - the theoretical cloaked ship (pre-2656) should have been as blind to the outside world as the outside world was to it. Second and probably of equal importance is the fact that energy does not disperse through a cloak field... and generating such a field requires that an exceptional amount of energy be produced. Heat and radiation will build up inside the field and eventually destroy the object if it remains cloaked.

The early Skipper Missiles got around both these problems by simply having the missile periodically decloak to reaquire their targets and vent energy. This wasn't a wildly succesful idea: having your invisible missile dump a massive amount of measurable energy into space during its attack run somewhat betrays the basic concept... and ultimately you simply have an exceptional expensive projectile. If anything, I would argue, the most effective aspect of the early, long-range Skippers was that they could better protect their launch platforms.

The Confederation saw this application of photon cloak technology in action beginning in 2654. My guess would be that the development of the Skipper probably did more to comfort Confederation analysts: they had known that the Empire was experimenting with theoretical photon cloaks for eight years... and what they ultimately encountered in combat was a weapon that very clearly ignored the technical problems rather than dealt with them.

Then we have the Strakha you're referring too, apparently build on a Sartha spaceframe. This weapon is wholly distinct from a photon cloak -- it's a stealth fighter along the lines of the modern F-117 Nighthawk... invisible to sensors but (as the episode makes abundantly clear) targetable by the naked eye. Again, this must have been reassuring to analysts: the Kilrathi had attempted to premiere a stealth fighter that completely abandoned the idea of a photon cloak.
 
Back
Top