How were cloaked ships countered? Pasted from HW2Mod thread

Mjr. Whoopass

<FONT color=lightblue><B>I was going to say someth
LeHah said:
a cloaked ship cannot be seen by sensors or by the human eye. (Stealth ships decloaking, attacking and recloaking around my mothership in the first Homeworld was bad enough - I cannot fathom the horror of Black Lance/Dragons doing the same thing!)

That's an interesting possibility since there really wasn't an 'anti-cloaking' device that we know of in the WC games. It might have been an extra element that Confed had to deal with; we know of the devestating results of such a nightmare when we hear about Kilrathi stealth ships decloaking and destroying Blair's ship, and he takes the blame for it.

Why that didn't continue and how Confed conceivably countered this threat; I don't know.. does Loaf have an explanation for how Confed dealt with this 'horror' and why the Kilrathi didn't destroy every Confed ship in this manner?
 
Were the strakha's not prototpyes from the shipyard the kilrathi destroyed to prevent the rebels from capturing and giving the technology to confed, just after the destruction of the tiger's claw? setting them back several years in progress?
 
Yes, as Thrakhath explains in Wing Commander II, the Ghorah Khar rebellion sets back development and production of cloaked fighters by eleven years. Production of Strakha doesn't resume until 2667, and then only in very limited numbers. We're told several times that the first small amounts of them are usually reserved for reconnaissance missions. Strakha seem to be a bit more common in the last weeks of the war, but the element of surprise is gone by then.

The reason the Tiger's Claw was destroyed so easily was because no one suspected that a completely invisible ship could exist... not because they're absolutely invulnerable. As you should all know from playing the games, intercepting a stealth fighter isn't impossible -- it just requires that you alter your tactics to adjust to them. Think of American Wildcat pilots coming up with special maneuvers to counter superior Japanese Zeros early in the Pacific War.

Anti-cloaking weapons were also developed very quickly. The Confederation had premiered the "Anti-Cloaking Gun" before the end of the war (in the Armada addon, Proving Grounds). In Wing Commander IV, we see the technology integrated into the new Lance fighters -- you can always see a white 'outline' of any cloaked fighter when you're flying one.

(And, of course, humans developed their own cloaking devices immediately, too. Shroud Devices were being used in combat in 2669, and a fully cloak version had been succesfully tested before the surrender. Once everyone has the bomb, no one has an advantage.)
 
Anti-cloaking weapons were also developed very quickly. The Confederation had premiered the "Anti-Cloaking Gun" before the end of the war (in the Armada addon, Proving Grounds). In Wing Commander IV, we see the technology integrated into the new Lance fighters -- you can always see a white 'outline' of any cloaked fighter when you're flying one.

Not to mention the sensor suite on Sabres (at the least, probably other ships as well) to burn through the cloak, as demonstrated by Hunter in Fleet Action.
 
Back
Top