Best and Worst WC ripoffs

dacis2

Spaceman
Best: Freespace series

Worst: I don't know, freespace is the only other space flight sim I've played.
 

cff

Kilk'dymga'qith laq Ik'vikvi
Well which games qualify as WC ripoffs?

If you are talking about space sims in general the best non WC one for me would be Tachyon the Fringe.
Worst space sim would be Freespace 1.

PS: Could someone remove that post/minute limit? I hate to hit that regulary ;)
 

Manic

Rear Admiral
The only thing that saved Tachyon from being the worst in my list is the fact that Bruce Cambell's in it. MY worst is Privateer II.
 

TCSTigersClaw

Greek Special Forces B' Company "Naoussa" 2007-200
HEY! Privateer2 is not a rippof, cause its a WingCommander game Manic!

Well,I dont know if they are rippofs or not but I like the X-Wing series....I think they are not rippofs at all.
I also like Starlancer (It is a rippos even if it is from ChrisRoberts)

I dislike Freespace1-2 :(
 

LeHah

212 Squadron - "The Old Man's Eyes And Ears"
Privateer 2 is a frickin awesome game.

I tried Freespace 2 for a day or so. I didn't have any problems with it myself, but I can see why people are so venomous towards it.
 

Aries

Vice Admiral
best: Starlancer or the Freespace series

Worst: don't know. the above are the only non-WC space sims i play
 

junior

Spaceman
Worst would probably be the one with the flying scorpions, Japanese helmets, etc... Can't for the life of me remember the name of it, though.
Best would probably be Star Raiders, except for the fact that it came first, so it would be a bit difficult to demonstrate its a rip-off.
 

Mav23

Swabbie
Banned
Originally posted by LeHah
I tried Freespace 2 for a day or so. I didn't have any problems with it myself, but I can see why people are so venomous towards it.

Why would people be venomous towards it?
 

Aries

Vice Admiral
hell yeah. the capship battles were fucking awsome! just think what a WC game would be like if they made the capships fight like in Freespace
 

Aries

Vice Admiral
hopefully that mod (named battlegroup Serpent or something like that) will fulfill that wish
 
Best... Come to think of it, I REALLY liked Starlancer. The battles, that is. The rest couldn't compare to Grim Fandango in a million years, or Wing Commander 3, for that matter.

Worst would have to be Tachyon, if you don't count Star Wars Starfighter (UGH!). THAT one's a REAL stinker!
 

LeHah

212 Squadron - "The Old Man's Eyes And Ears"
Star Wars Starfighter kicked serious butt. My only complaint would be the canyon levels. I'd've liked to have been able to leave the trench, ya know?

Anyway, Jedi Starfighter was better; they cleaned up a lot of the little problems in it.
 

Wulf

Vice Admiral
I like Tachyon for the fact it has MP on Novaworld, one of the more popular online MP areas. There's always plenty of butt to kick.
 

iCe

Vice Admiral
Well, i don't know what games are rip-off's but looking at how the games look and play i would say the Freespace is the best, and battle cruiser 3000 the worst
 
Top