Originally posted by Mekt-Hakkikt
Sivar's ways are not so obvious and for an ape it is impossible to comprehend his wisdom.
In other words, you can't refute me so you muddy the
waters.
It is nowhere written that any Kilrathi begged sth from the Terrans.
Because the Kilrathi, in addition to being bloodthirsty
and depraved, are notorious Liars. Confed certainly
DID give Pasqual 10 to the Kilrathi at Melek's request.
And the Kilrathi were the ones who sued for peace (twice!)
For "sued" read "begged and grovelled pathetically".
The first time because the K. couldn't beat the "weak"
humans in a stand-up fight, and had to resort to treachery.
The second time because their home planet, their emperor,
and their Grand Fleet massed in Kilrah orbit was gone.
And the Kilrathi surely destroyed that bug carrier faster and more efficiently than the Terrans destroyed the cruiser. And that although they used old ships.
Yes, they did destroy the carrier quickly. Because
they had Human pilots flying escort for them and
protecting them from the Mantas and Devil Rays who
would otherwise surely have destroyed them. And because
most of the escorts had been drawn off by a HUMAN diversion, led by Maj. Marshall. So far, all this demonstrates is that the Kilrathi can successfully shoot a stationary, inadequately defended target. But we knew that already. As they demonstrated at Mcauliffe, that's what
they're best at. Now, when there's an opponent with
any reasonable combat effectiveness, the Kilrathi
have trouble. In other words, they are best against
unarmed foes, and sue for peace or resort to treachery
when confronted with effective ones.
We have a word for this in English: We call it COWARDICE.
That's also a single datum point. Against the glorious
achievement of destroying a lightly defended carrier
with significant human help you must set their
performance in the Cult of Sivar Rescue (LOUSY), and their
performance in Midway's defense (PATHETIC).
In all three of these engagements, compare Kilrathi
kill count to Confed Kill Count. Then compare Kilrathi
casualties to Confed Casualties. Then tell me again
how the Kilrathi are *so* much better than humans. BAH!
Of course you might get the (strong) impression that those bugs are the star gods, still it is nowhere stated explicitly. It is just a possibility...
This is a silly tactic that defense lawyers use when
defending otherwise-indefensible clients. "Well, how
do you know FOR SURE that you saw...". "Is it really
reasonable that he could have seen X? Aren't you making
this up?"
They do this when they have no FACTS to back up their
version of events, nor indeed any plausible alternative
explanation. So they seek to confuse the issue
by creating a fog of doubt, in the hope that the jury
will be befuddled enough to have "reasonable doubt". BAH!
If they are not the Star Gods, then give me a good
alternative 'canonical' explanation -- especially when
the writers most likely invented the whole Prophecy
thing as intro for the bugs!
-- Brian P.